Best Years for Subaru Forester: Reliable Models

The Subaru Forester has long been a favorite in the compact SUV market, known for its all-wheel-drive system, safety features, and reliability.

Consumer Reports has consistently rated the Subaru Forester highly for reliability and customer satisfaction. Over the years, the Forester has evolved through five generations, each bringing improvements and addressing previous issues. In this autoDNA’s guide, we’ll delve into the best years for Subaru Forester, highlight the key features of each generation, and provide a ranking of the top models.

 

Subaru Forester First Generation (Model Year: 1998-2002)

The first-generation Subaru Forester, which debuted in 1998, marked the brand’s entry into the rapidly growing compact SUV segment. This generation laid the foundation for the Forester’s reputation as a reliable, versatile, and rugged vehicle, combining the practicality of an SUV with the handling and performance of a car. Here’s a closer look at what made the first-generation Forester a standout model.

• Engine Options: 2.5L H4
• Transmission: 5-speed manual or 4-speed automatic
• Drivetrain: AWD

The 1998 Forester featured a boxy, utilitarian design that prioritized function over form. This design ethos was in line with Subaru’s focus on practicality and reliability. The elevated ride height and standard all-wheel-drive system made it capable of handling a variety of road conditions, from city streets to rugged off-road trails.

Equipped with a 2.5L H4 engine, the first-generation Forester provided sufficient power for both daily driving and weekend adventures. The engine was paired with either a 5-speed manual or a 4-speed automatic transmission, offering flexibility for different driving preferences. The manual transmission, in particular, appealed to enthusiasts who appreciated the more engaged driving experience.

Inside, the first-generation Forester offered a spacious interior with ample headroom and legroom, making it comfortable for both driver and passengers. The high seating position provided excellent visibility, a feature that became one of the Forester’s signature attributes. While the interior design was straightforward and functional, it lacked some of the modern conveniences found in later models. However, it did include essential features such as air conditioning, power windows, and an AM/FM radio.

Subaru’s commitment to safety was evident even in this early model. The first-generation Forester included standard safety features such as dual airbags and anti-lock brakes. Its sturdy build and reliable AWD system contributed to its reputation as a safe and dependable vehicle.

 

First generation of Subaru Forester – Common Issues

Despite its many strengths, the first-generation Forester was not without its issues. Some model years of the first-generation Forester are considered forester years to avoid due to common issues. Owners reported problems such as:

• Head Gasket Failures: This was a common issue in many Subaru models from this era, including the Forester. Historical problems with head gaskets in earlier model years highlighted the importance of early detection and timely repairs to prevent significant engine damage.
• Excessive Oil Consumption: Some owners experienced higher-than-expected oil consumption, necessitating more frequent oil changes and monitoring.
• Timing Belt Replacement: Regular maintenance was essential, particularly the timely replacement of the timing belt to avoid engine problems.

In conclusion, the first-generation Subaru Forester was a groundbreaking model that introduced many of the qualities that have since become synonymous with the Forester name. Its rugged build, reliable performance, and practical design made it a standout choice in the late 1990s and early 2000s, setting a high standard for subsequent generations to follow.

 

Subaru Forester Second Generation (Model Year: 2003-2008)

The second-generation Subaru Forester, introduced in 2003, brought significant advancements in performance, safety, and overall design. Building on the success of its predecessor, this generation offered a more refined driving experience while addressing some of the earlier model’s shortcomings. Here’s a detailed look at what made the second-generation Forester stand out.

• Engine Options: 2.5L H4, 2.5L Turbo H4
• Transmission: 5-speed manual or 4-speed automatic
• Drivetrain: AWD

The second-generation Forester featured a more modern and streamlined design compared to the first generation. Subaru aimed to attract a broader audience by enhancing the vehicle’s aesthetics without compromising its ruggedness and practicality. The revised exterior included sleeker lines, a more aerodynamic profile, and improved overall build quality. These changes not only improved the Forester’s visual appeal but also contributed to better fuel efficiency.

One of the most notable upgrades in the second-generation Forester was the introduction of a turbocharged engine option. The 2.5L Turbo H4 engine significantly boosted the vehicle’s power and performance, making it an attractive choice for driving enthusiasts. The turbocharged variant, known as the Forester XT, offered increased horsepower and torque, providing a more spirited and engaging driving experience. Both engine options were paired with either a 5-speed manual or a 4-speed automatic transmission, allowing drivers to choose their preferred driving style.

The interior of the second-generation Forester saw considerable improvements in terms of comfort and functionality. The cabin was designed with higher-quality materials, providing a more premium feel. Enhanced seating comfort and improved ergonomics made long drives more enjoyable for both the driver and passengers. Additionally, the Forester offered a more spacious interior, with increased cargo space and versatile seating arrangements, making it ideal for families and outdoor activities.

Safety was a major focus in the second-generation Forester. Subaru introduced several advanced safety features to enhance driver and passenger protection. Standard safety equipment included:

• Dual Front Airbags
• Side-Impact Airbags
• Anti-Lock Brakes (ABS)
• Stability Control System

These features contributed to high safety ratings from various automotive safety organizations.

 

 

Second generation of Subaru Forester – Common Issues

While the second-generation Forester was praised for its improvements, it also had some common issues reported by owners:

• Head Gasket Problems: Although improved, head gasket issues were still present, particularly in non-turbo models. These head gasket problems were a common issue in many Subaru vehicles, including the Forester, during this era.
• Oil Consumption: Some owners experienced excessive oil consumption, requiring diligent monitoring and maintenance.
• CVT Transmission: Early models with CVT had some reliability issues, which Subaru later addressed in subsequent updates.

In conclusion, the second-generation Subaru Forester (2003-2008) was a major step forward for the model line. Its combination of turbocharged power, enhanced safety, and improved interior comfort made it a compelling choice in the compact SUV market.

 

Subaru Forester Third Generation (Model Year: 2009-2013)

The third-generation Subaru Forester, launched in 2009, marked a significant evolution in the model’s design, performance, and overall appeal. With a focus on refinement and versatility, this generation brought numerous enhancements that appealed to a broader audience. Let’s delve into the key features and improvements that defined the third-generation Forester.

• Engine Options: 2.5L H4, 2.5L Turbo H4
• Transmission: 5-speed manual or 4-speed automatic
• Drivetrain: AWD

The third-generation Forester featured a complete redesign, adopting a more contemporary and sophisticated look. The exterior was more rounded and aerodynamic compared to previous models, enhancing both its aesthetic appeal and fuel efficiency. The new design also included larger windows for better visibility and a higher ground clearance, making it more capable on various terrains.

The third-generation Forester offered a refined driving experience with its improved suspension and chassis. The standard 2.5L H4 engine provided reliable performance for daily driving, while the 2.5L Turbo H4 engine, available in the Forester XT, delivered exhilarating power for those seeking more excitement behind the wheel. The turbocharged model boasted impressive acceleration and handling, making it one of the sportiest compact SUVs in its class.

 

The cabin was significantly larger, offering increased legroom and headroom for both front and rear passengers. The rear seats were designed to fold flat, expanding the already generous cargo space and making it easier to transport large items. High-quality materials and improved ergonomics contributed to a more premium feel, while features such as a panoramic sunroof, heated seats, and advanced audio systems enhanced overall comfort and convenience. Subaru continued its commitment to safety with the third-generation Forester. The model included a range of standard safety features, such as:

• Advanced Airbag System: Dual front, side, and curtain airbags provided comprehensive protection.
• Vehicle Dynamics Control: This stability control system helped maintain vehicle control in challenging driving conditions.
• Anti-Lock Braking System (ABS): Enhanced braking performance for improved safety.

In addition to these features, the Forester’s robust AWD system ensured excellent traction and stability, particularly in adverse weather conditions, contributing to its high safety ratings.

 

Third generation of Subaru Forester – Common Issues

Despite its many improvements, the third-generation Forester had some common issues reported by owners:

• Oil Consumption: Excessive oil consumption remained a concern, particularly in models with higher mileage.
• Head Gasket Problems: While less common than in earlier generations, some head gasket issues were still reported in Subaru Foresters of this generation. This issue, although reduced, still affected the reliability of certain model years.
• Suspension Wear: Over time, components of the suspension system, such as the rear lower control arms, showed signs of wear and needed replacement.

Owners of the third-generation Forester generally expressed high levels of satisfaction, appreciating the blend of comfort, performance, and versatility. Additionally, the turbocharged XT model attracted those looking for a sporty, yet practical, compact SUV.

 

Subaru Forester Fourth Generation (Model Year: 2014-2018)

The fourth-generation Subaru Forester, spanning the model years 2014 to 2018, represented a significant leap forward in terms of efficiency, technology, and overall driving experience. This generation of the Forester was designed to meet the demands of modern drivers, offering advanced features and improved performance while maintaining the core attributes that made the Forester a popular choice among compact SUVs. Here’s an in-depth look at what the fourth-generation Forester brought to the table.

• Engine Options: 2.5L H4, 2.0L Turbo H4
• Transmission: 6-speed manual or CVT
• Drivetrain: AWD

The 4th-generation Forester featured a more aerodynamic and contemporary design compared to its predecessors. The exterior was sleek and stylish, with sharp lines and a bold front grille that gave it a distinctive look. The improved aerodynamics contributed to better fuel efficiency, a critical factor for modern consumers. Additionally, the body was constructed with high-strength steel, enhancing durability and safety.

The 2014-2018 Forester offered two engine options: the reliable 2.5L H4 engine and the more powerful 2.0L Turbo H4 engine. The turbocharged variant, available in the Forester XT, provided a thrilling driving experience with its increased horsepower and torque. The introduction of the continuously variable transmission (CVT) improved fuel efficiency and offered a smoother driving experience. For those who preferred a more hands-on approach, a 6-speed manual transmission was also available, catering to driving enthusiasts.

The interior of the 4th generation Forester was designed with modernity and comfort in mind. It featured high-quality materials, intuitive controls, and a spacious layout that provided ample room for passengers and cargo. Key interior enhancements included:

• Panoramic Sunroof: Offered a more open and airy feel to the cabin.
• Heated Seats: Enhanced comfort during colder months.
• Advanced Infotainment System: Included features such as Bluetooth connectivity, a touchscreen interface, and optional navigation.

The rear seats could be folded flat to create a substantial cargo area, making the Forester a versatile option for families and adventure seekers. The elevated driving position and large windows provided excellent visibility, a trademark of the Forester’s design.

Safety was a paramount concern in the 4th generation Forester, which included a suite of advanced safety features:

• EyeSight Driver Assist Technology: A groundbreaking system that included adaptive cruise control, pre-collision braking, and lane departure warning.
• Rearview Camera: Standard in all models, aiding in reversing and parking.
• Advanced Airbag System: Provided comprehensive protection for all occupants.

These features contributed to the Forester’s high safety ratings and made it one of the safest vehicles in its class.

 

Fourth generation of Subaru Forester – Common Issues

While the 4th-generation Forester was highly regarded, some common issues were reported by owners:

• Oil Consumption: Excessive oil consumption was a recurring problem, particularly in the earlier Subaru Forester models of this generation. This issue affected the reliability and customer satisfaction of these models.
• CVT Issues: Some owners reported problems with the CVT transmission, including hesitation and rough shifting.
• Suspension Wear: Over time, components of the suspension system, such as the rear lower control arms, required maintenance or replacement.

In conclusion, the fourth-generation Subaru Forester (2014-2018) was a significant step forward for the model, offering modern efficiency and advanced technology that appealed to contemporary drivers. Its combination of enhanced performance, safety features, and interior comfort made it a standout choice in the compact SUV market. Whether for daily commuting, family road trips, or outdoor adventures, the 4th-generation Forester provided a well-rounded and reliable vehicle that met a wide range of needs and preferences.

 

Subaru Forester Fifth Generation (Model Year: 2019-Present)

The fifth-generation Subaru Forester, introduced in 2019 and continuing to the present, represents the pinnacle of Subaru’s commitment to safety, comfort, and advanced technology. This generation builds upon the strengths of its predecessors while incorporating state-of-the-art features and enhancements that cater to the needs of modern drivers. Let’s explore the standout aspects of the fifth-generation Forester in detail.

• Engine Options: 2.5L H4
• Transmission: CVT
• Drivetrain: AWD

The fifth-generation Forester features a sleek, contemporary design that emphasizes both aesthetics and functionality. The exterior is characterized by a bold front grille, stylish headlights, and a streamlined body that improves aerodynamics. The use of high-strength steel in the construction enhances durability and crash safety, making the Forester one of the safest vehicles in its class.

Under the hood, the fifth-generation Forester is powered by a 2.5L H4 engine that delivers a balance of power and efficiency. The engine is paired with a continuously variable transmission (CVT), which provides smooth acceleration and improved fuel economy. The Forester’s symmetrical all-wheel-drive system ensures excellent traction and stability in various driving conditions, from city streets to off-road trails.

The interior of the fifth-generation Forester is designed to provide maximum comfort and convenience for both the driver and passengers. Key features include:

• Spacious Cabin: The Forester offers ample legroom and headroom for all occupants, with a particularly roomy rear seat area.
• High-Quality Materials: Soft-touch surfaces, premium upholstery, and refined finishes create a luxurious feel.
• Advanced Infotainment System: A user-friendly interface with a large touchscreen, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and available navigation.

Additional comfort features such as heated seats, dual-zone climate control, and a panoramic sunroof enhance the overall driving experience. The Forester also offers a generous cargo space, with rear seats that fold flat to accommodate larger items, making it an ideal vehicle for families and adventurers alike.

The fifth-generation Forester is equipped with a comprehensive suite of advanced safety features, reflecting Subaru’s commitment to protecting its drivers and passengers:

• EyeSight Driver Assist Technology: Includes adaptive cruise control, lane departure and sway warning, pre-collision braking, and lane keep assist.
• DriverFocus Distraction Mitigation System: Uses facial recognition technology to monitor the driver’s attention and provide alerts if signs of distraction or fatigue are detected.
• Rear Cross-Traffic Alert and Blind-Spot Detection: Enhance situational awareness and help prevent accidents.

These cutting-edge safety technologies contribute to the Forester’s high safety ratings and its reputation as one of the safest vehicles on the road.

 

Fifth generation of Subaru Forester – Common Issues

While the fifth-generation Forester is generally well-regarded, some owners have reported common issues, including:

• CVT Transmission: Some drivers have noted issues with the CVT, such as hesitation and rough shifting, although these are less frequent compared to earlier models.
• Oil Consumption: Excessive oil consumption has been reported by a minority of owners, requiring more frequent oil checks and maintenance. This issue is also noted among some used Subaru Forester models from this generation, making it important to check the maintenance history and oil consumption patterns when considering a purchase.
• Infotainment System Glitches: Occasional glitches with the infotainment system have been noted, including issues with connectivity and software updates.

In conclusion, the fifth-generation Subaru Forester exemplifies cutting-edge safety and comfort, making it one of the most advanced and appealing compact SUVs on the market. Its combination of modern technology, robust performance, and luxurious interior make it a standout choice for a wide range of drivers, from families to outdoor enthusiasts. Whether navigating city streets or exploring off-road trails, the fifth-generation Forester delivers a superior driving experience that meets the demands of contemporary lifestyles.

 

Ranking the Best Subaru Forester Years: Top Picks, Highlights, and Years to Avoid

Based on reliability, safety, and modern features, here are the top picks for the best Subaru Forester years:

1. 2016-2018: Known for their balance of performance, reliability, and modern features.
2. 2021-Present: Praised for advanced safety technologies and comfort.
3. 2014-2016: These years offer a great combination of safety, efficiency, and capability.

 

Common Problems with Subaru Forester: Excessive Oil Consumption and What to Watch Out For

While the Subaru Forester is generally reliable, there are some common issues to be aware of when considering it as a used car:

• Oil Consumption: Excessive oil consumption has been reported, particularly in the 3rd and 4th generations.
• CVT Issues: Some models have experienced problems with the CVT transmission, especially in earlier years.
• Head Gasket Failures: This issue is more common in older models, particularly from the first and second generations.
• Suspension Problems: Wear and tear on the rear suspension components can be an issue.